Sherlock Holmes Movie Review and discussion

Rupali · 09-01-2010, 11:45 AM

Story: Sherlock Holmes and his assistant, Dr John Watson think they have successfully resolved a case, when the murderer, Lord Blackwood is hanged for his crimes. But the black-magic practitioner returns from the dead to haunt London once again. Time to take up the case again.

Movie Review: Sherlock Holmes with a whole lot of hormones? Now that's not so elementary, my dear Watson! Specially, when entire generations of readers have grown up with memories of a vintage arm chair detective who never actually got his hands soiled, despite spending a lifetime tackling crime and criminals.

But here, there's not only a whole lot of bone-crunching and rib-busting that Holmes joyously indulges in, there's his perpetual grubby look, his overnight stubble, stained shirt and dissolute, world-weary attitude that totally reinvents the character, lock, stock and two smokin' barrels (read Guy Ritchie style). Add to this Robert Downey Jr.'s inherent edginess as reflected in his on and off screen personae and you have Arthur Conan Doyle's Victorian hero give up his deerstalker hat for a rakish insouciance that doesn't make him the most popular inhabitant of 221B Baker Street. Add to this the slight hint of a bromance between the mercurial Holmes and the more grounded Watson (Jude Law) and you have a complete make over of the classic detective series that thrills but doesn't dazzle.

May be it's the shadowy figure of Holmes arch nemesis, Professor Moriarty, that creates somewhat of an unequal fight in this, the detective's first outing. The filmmaker does promise to bring us Brad Pitt in the sequel, flashing his brand of evil, as Moriarty. But for now, we must contend with a flesh and blood baddie who doesn't really bring out the chills: Lord Blackwood (Mark Strong), the practitioner of black magic who dreams of creating a new world order, born out of fear. The trouble with Blackwood is he's too much a Dan Brownish character, a member of a special sect, worshipping ancient rituals and traditions, dreaming of world supremacy. This does fill you with a dense of deja vu and makes you long for Conan Doyle's mean criminals, minus the mumbo jumbo.

Holmes, sulking at the thought of being separated from Watson who's moving out and getting married, is forcibly drawn out of his isolation at the behest of a to-be-hanged Blackwood. The dark lord promises to return after his death and wreak havoc on London, like never before. And return he does, sending the city in a tizzy. Because, as they say, when the dead return, the living begin to die. Holmes' problems suddenly seem to multiply. He must not only contend with Watson's impending separation and Blackwood's evil second coming, there's also his former girlfriend, the delectable thief, Irene Adler (Rachel McAdams) tormenting him with her tantalising comings and goings. So much, while a French-speaking assassin insists on pummelling him to pulp, Scotland Yard declares him a fugitive and the occult-worshipping Blackwood threatens to clean up the British Parliament....

Indeed, the reinvention of Sherlock Holmes does work well, even as a testosterone-high Holmes dons the superman mantle with glee. Foggy London is vintage and winsomely captured by cinematographer Philippe Rousellot and Hans Zimmer's music score provides a perfect backdrop tenor. But it is eventually the chemistry between Holmes and Watson (Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law) that adds wit and sparkle to the film. Incidentally, it works better than the Holmes and Adler (Downey Jr. and Rachel McAdams) romance.

Go, watch another of your heroes get in step with the times.

maria · 10-01-2010, 06:40 PM

Watch the trailer of Sherlock Holmes

abhishek · 02-04-2010, 07:34 AM

It was one of the worst movies on Sherlock Holmes. There was no seriousness in his character, rather he was portrayed as a comedian.

Sushil · 23-04-2010, 11:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by abhishek

It was one of the worst movies on Sherlock Holmes. There was no seriousness in his character, rather he was portrayed as a comedian.

Haven't watch Sherlock yet but heard, Movie were a successful movie other then Avatar or Twilight Saga: new moon.

jitendragarg · 23-04-2010, 12:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sushil

Haven't watch Sherlock yet but heard, Movie were a successful movie other then Avatar or Twilight Saga: new moon.

No justice to the character, man, then how can a movie be good. Although plot was good, totally different and with lots of twists and turns, just like what you should expect in a Sherlock Holmes movie. But still, Sherlock holmes was one of the most decent character ever portrayed in a novel. Showing him as a flirt, fun and totally reckless, is just not good.

Sushil · 26-04-2010, 11:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jitendragarg

No justice to the character, man, then how can a movie be good. Although plot was good, totally different and with lots of twists and turns, just like what you should expect in a Sherlock Holmes movie. But still, Sherlock holmes was one of the most decent character ever portrayed in a novel. Showing him as a flirt, fun and totally reckless, is just not good.

Nice point you have detect form Sherlock Holmes, m agree with you a lil

drewgrantt · 08-06-2010, 03:40 PM

Guy Ritchie's noisy steampunk mauling of Arthur Conan Doyle's character is great galloping fun if ultimately slighter and less nervy than we might have hoped. Still, Robert Downey Jr. is great fun to watch and Jude Law has a clue.

johnmartin · 25-10-2010, 10:56 AM

Thanks for reviews ! This is the greatest review I ever read. I am surely go for this film. the film sounds to be good one.

jamesgibses · 20-12-2010, 07:48 PM

Sherlock Holmes is one of the great movie. This extraordinary show of work of nature seems to be little interest in Holmes, however, and he barely looked up from under her dress, as we made our way through the heart of Carnival City. The location of the city is very interesting and scary.

jamesnjackson · 23-12-2010, 06:41 PM

Sherlock Holmes is really a great movie according to me. There are very suspenseful scenes are available in this movie. It began as the film draws to a close brazenly set up a sequel, and give a wide range of Sherlock Holmes and Watson in the adventure, said Arthur Conan Doyle. This one is just a thunder movie.

09-01-2010, 11:45 AM	#1
Rupali Member Join Date: Dec 2009 Posts: 43 Rep Power: 0	Sherlock Holmes Movie Review and discussion Story: Sherlock Holmes and his assistant, Dr John Watson think they have successfully resolved a case, when the murderer, Lord Blackwood is hanged for his crimes. But the black-magic practitioner returns from the dead to haunt London once again. Time to take up the case again. Movie Review: Sherlock Holmes with a whole lot of hormones? Now that's not so elementary, my dear Watson! Specially, when entire generations of readers have grown up with memories of a vintage arm chair detective who never actually got his hands soiled, despite spending a lifetime tackling crime and criminals. But here, there's not only a whole lot of bone-crunching and rib-busting that Holmes joyously indulges in, there's his perpetual grubby look, his overnight stubble, stained shirt and dissolute, world-weary attitude that totally reinvents the character, lock, stock and two smokin' barrels (read Guy Ritchie style). Add to this Robert Downey Jr.'s inherent edginess as reflected in his on and off screen personae and you have Arthur Conan Doyle's Victorian hero give up his deerstalker hat for a rakish insouciance that doesn't make him the most popular inhabitant of 221B Baker Street. Add to this the slight hint of a bromance between the mercurial Holmes and the more grounded Watson (Jude Law) and you have a complete make over of the classic detective series that thrills but doesn't dazzle. May be it's the shadowy figure of Holmes arch nemesis, Professor Moriarty, that creates somewhat of an unequal fight in this, the detective's first outing. The filmmaker does promise to bring us Brad Pitt in the sequel, flashing his brand of evil, as Moriarty. But for now, we must contend with a flesh and blood baddie who doesn't really bring out the chills: Lord Blackwood (Mark Strong), the practitioner of black magic who dreams of creating a new world order, born out of fear. The trouble with Blackwood is he's too much a Dan Brownish character, a member of a special sect, worshipping ancient rituals and traditions, dreaming of world supremacy. This does fill you with a dense of deja vu and makes you long for Conan Doyle's mean criminals, minus the mumbo jumbo. Holmes, sulking at the thought of being separated from Watson who's moving out and getting married, is forcibly drawn out of his isolation at the behest of a to-be-hanged Blackwood. The dark lord promises to return after his death and wreak havoc on London, like never before. And return he does, sending the city in a tizzy. Because, as they say, when the dead return, the living begin to die. Holmes' problems suddenly seem to multiply. He must not only contend with Watson's impending separation and Blackwood's evil second coming, there's also his former girlfriend, the delectable thief, Irene Adler (Rachel McAdams) tormenting him with her tantalising comings and goings. So much, while a French-speaking assassin insists on pummelling him to pulp, Scotland Yard declares him a fugitive and the occult-worshipping Blackwood threatens to clean up the British Parliament.... Indeed, the reinvention of Sherlock Holmes does work well, even as a testosterone-high Holmes dons the superman mantle with glee. Foggy London is vintage and winsomely captured by cinematographer Philippe Rousellot and Hans Zimmer's music score provides a perfect backdrop tenor. But it is eventually the chemistry between Holmes and Watson (Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law) that adds wit and sparkle to the film. Incidentally, it works better than the Holmes and Adler (Downey Jr. and Rachel McAdams) romance. Go, watch another of your heroes get in step with the times.

02-04-2010, 07:34 AM	#3
abhishek Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2009 Posts: 444 Rep Power: 18	It was one of the worst movies on Sherlock Holmes. There was no seriousness in his character, rather he was portrayed as a comedian. __________________ Join this forum, it's completely free.

20-12-2010, 07:48 PM	#9
jamesgibses Junior Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Posts: 3 Rep Power: 0	Re: Sherlock Holmes Movie Review and discussion Sherlock Holmes is one of the great movie. This extraordinary show of work of nature seems to be little interest in Holmes, however, and he barely looked up from under her dress, as we made our way through the heart of Carnival City. The location of the city is very interesting and scary.

23-12-2010, 06:41 PM	#10
jamesnjackson Junior Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Posts: 4 Rep Power: 0	Re: Sherlock Holmes Movie Review and discussion Sherlock Holmes is really a great movie according to me. There are very suspenseful scenes are available in this movie. It began as the film draws to a close brazenly set up a sequel, and give a wide range of Sherlock Holmes and Watson in the adventure, said Arthur Conan Doyle. This one is just a thunder movie.

10-01-2010, 06:40 PM	#2
maria Member Join Date: Dec 2009 Posts: 30 Rep Power: 0	Watch the trailer of Sherlock Holmes

08-06-2010, 03:40 PM	#7
drewgrantt Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2010 Posts: 5 Rep Power: 0	Guy Ritchie's noisy steampunk mauling of Arthur Conan Doyle's character is great galloping fun if ultimately slighter and less nervy than we might have hoped. Still, Robert Downey Jr. is great fun to watch and Jude Law has a clue.

25-10-2010, 10:56 AM	#8
johnmartin Member Join Date: Sep 2010 Posts: 20 Rep Power: 0	Thanks for reviews ! This is the greatest review I ever read. I am surely go for this film. the film sounds to be good one.